Will Progressive insure a rebuilt title?

We may earn a commission for purchases through links on our site at no cost to you, Learn more.

You found a car that seems perfect. The price is significantly lower than other cars of the same make and model. The seller informs you the vehicle has a rebuilt title. This information brings up an important question for any potential buyer: can you get insurance for it? Specifically, you need to know if a major provider like Progressive will offer you a policy. The answer is critical. It determines if your great deal is a smart purchase or a future problem.

This guide will provide a clear and detailed answer. We will explain what a rebuilt title is, how insurance companies view these vehicles, and the exact steps you need to take. We will focus on Progressive’s policies to give you the information you need to make a confident decision. The short answer is yes, Progressive often insures vehicles with rebuilt titles. However, the process involves specific requirements and potential limitations on your coverage.

Understanding the journey of a car from a total loss to a road-ready vehicle with a rebuilt title is the first step. This knowledge helps you understand an insurer’s perspective. It shows why they have extra requirements for these cars. Knowing this background makes the insurance application process much clearer.

What is a Rebuilt Title? A Clear Definition

A vehicle title is a legal document. It proves ownership of a car. Most cars on the road have a clean title. A clean title indicates the vehicle has never been declared a total loss by an insurance company. A rebuilt title tells a different story.

A car gets a rebuilt title after it was previously issued a salvage title and has since been repaired and deemed roadworthy through a state inspection process. This history is central to how insurers, including Progressive, assess the vehicle.

The Journey from Salvage to Rebuilt

The process begins when a vehicle sustains significant damage. This damage can come from a collision, flood, fire, hail, or even theft and recovery. An insurance adjuster inspects the vehicle to estimate the cost of repairs. If the repair cost exceeds a certain percentage of the vehicle’s pre-damage value, the insurer declares it a “total loss.” This percentage varies by state and insurance company but is often around 70% to 90%.

At this point, the insurance company pays the owner for the car’s value and takes possession of the vehicle. The state’s Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) then issues a “salvage title” for that car. A salvage title means the vehicle is not legal to drive on public roads. It can only be sold to a licensed rebuilder or used for parts.

Someone then purchases the salvage vehicle. This person or body shop performs the necessary repairs to bring the car back to a safe, operational condition. After the repairs are complete, the vehicle must undergo a thorough inspection by a designated state facility. This inspection verifies that the car is roadworthy and that the repairs meet safety standards. If the vehicle passes this inspection, the DMV issues a new “rebuilt” title. This title permanently brands the vehicle’s history, informing all future owners and insurers of its past. The question of will progressive insure a rebuilt title is directly tied to the quality of these repairs and the certification from this state inspection.

Why Cars Get Rebuilt Titles

The “total loss” designation is a financial decision, not always a mechanical one. A late-model luxury car might sustain heavy frame damage and not be totaled because its high value justifies expensive repairs. In contrast, an older, reliable car might be totaled from a minor fender-bender. If the car’s value is only $5,000, and repairs cost $4,000, it is a financial total loss. Yet, the car could be perfectly repairable.

This financial calculation is why many rebuilt title cars can be excellent vehicles. They were simply not worth fixing from the insurer’s economic viewpoint. Common reasons for a salvage title that leads to a rebuilt title include:

• Collision Damage: This is the most frequent cause. The damage could range from cosmetic issues to significant structural repairs.
• Flood Damage: Water can cause severe, hard-to-detect damage to electronics, upholstery, and mechanical systems. Insurers are often very cautious with flood-damaged cars.
• Hail Damage: Widespread cosmetic damage from hail can be expensive to fix. While it might not affect the car’s function, the repair cost can lead to a total loss declaration.
• Theft Recovery: A car might be stolen and later recovered. If it was recovered after the insurance claim was paid, it will receive a salvage title, even if it has no damage at all. These can be some of the best-rebuilt vehicle candidates.

Progressive’s Official Policy on Rebuilt Title Vehicles

Insurance companies manage risk. A rebuilt title represents a vehicle with an unknown history of repairs. The quality of those repairs can vary greatly. Poorly repaired structural damage could compromise the car’s safety in a future accident. Hidden electrical issues from a flood could appear months later. This uncertainty is why some insurance companies refuse to cover rebuilt titles at all.

Progressive, however, takes a more flexible approach. The company understands that many rebuilt vehicles are safe and reliable. They are willing to offer insurance on these cars, but they have a process to verify the vehicle’s condition and limit their own risk.

The Direct Answer

Yes, Progressive will insure a car with a rebuilt title. However, the availability of coverage and the types of coverage you can purchase depend on several factors. Progressive will almost always offer liability coverage for a rebuilt title vehicle, provided it has passed the required state safety inspection and is deemed roadworthy. State laws mandate liability coverage for all vehicles on the road, so insurers are equipped to provide this basic protection. Liability coverage pays for damages you cause to other people and their property. It does not cover damage to your own vehicle.

The more complex issue is physical damage coverage. This includes:

• Collision Coverage: This pays to repair your car after an accident with another object or vehicle.
• Comprehensive Coverage: This pays for damage from non-collision events, such as theft, vandalism, fire, or hitting an animal.

Progressive may or may not offer collision and comprehensive coverage for a rebuilt title car. Their decision is made on a case-by-case basis. They will want to assess the vehicle themselves to determine the quality of the repairs. The final decision on whether you can get full coverage is a crucial part of the answer to the question “will progressive insure a rebuilt title”. For many drivers, liability-only insurance is not enough protection for their investment.

The Importance of a State Inspection

Before you even contact Progressive, your rebuilt vehicle must have passed its state-mandated inspection. This is a non-negotiable first step. This inspection is performed by the DMV or an authorized law enforcement agency. The inspectors are looking for specific things to ensure the car is safe for the road. They check that critical safety components like airbags, seatbelts, brakes, and lights are all functioning correctly. They also verify that the vehicle’s frame is structurally sound. You will receive an official certificate upon passing this inspection. This certificate is the document that allows the DMV to change the title from “salvage” to “rebuilt.”

This inspection certificate is the first piece of evidence you will present to Progressive. It proves that the car has met the minimum safety standards set by your state. Without it, your application for insurance will not proceed.

How to Get Insurance for Your Rebuilt Car from Progressive

Getting insurance for a rebuilt title vehicle from Progressive requires more steps than insuring a car with a clean title. You must be proactive and provide detailed documentation. A simple online quote form may not work. The system might automatically flag the Vehicle Identification Number (VIN) and require you to speak with an agent. Following a clear process will increase your chances of getting the coverage you want.

Step 1: Gather Your Documents

Preparation is key. Before you call Progressive, you should assemble a complete file on your vehicle’s history and repair. This file demonstrates transparency and shows that the vehicle was repaired properly. The more information you can provide, the more confident Progressive can be in insuring your car. Your file should include:

• The Rebuilt Title: This is the primary legal document.
• State Inspection Certificate: This proves the car has passed its mandatory safety check.
• Original Repair Estimates: If possible, get the original insurance adjuster’s report that detailed the damage before repairs began.
• Photos of the Damage: Pre-repair photos are very helpful. They show the extent of the original damage and prove what was fixed.
• Receipts for Parts and Labor: Keep a detailed list of all new parts used in the repair. Also, keep receipts from the body shop that performed the work. This documentation shows that quality components and professional labor were used.

Having this information ready proves that you have done your due diligence. It makes the underwriting process smoother and directly impacts the answer to will progressive insure a rebuilt title for your specific car. A well-documented repair history can be the difference between getting full coverage and being offered liability only.

Step 2: Contact Progressive Directly

Do not rely solely on the online quote tool. The best approach is to call Progressive and speak directly with a licensed agent. When you call, state clearly that you are seeking insurance for a vehicle with a rebuilt title. The agent will know the specific procedure to follow.

Be prepared to answer detailed questions about the car. The agent will ask about the nature of the original damage (collision, flood, etc.), the repairs that were made, and the current condition of the vehicle. This is where your document file becomes invaluable. You can provide precise answers and even offer to email copies of your documents to the agent or underwriter. Honesty and transparency are critical during this conversation. Hiding information about the car’s past will likely lead to a denial of coverage or problems with a future claim.

Step 3: The Progressive Vehicle Inspection

In many cases, especially if you are seeking comprehensive and collision coverage, Progressive will require its own inspection of the vehicle. This is separate from and in addition to the state-level inspection you have already completed. Progressive’s inspection is for their own risk assessment. They need to see the quality of the repairs firsthand.

A Progressive representative or an inspector from a third-party service they use will schedule a time to see your car. They will look at:

• Cosmetic Finish: They will check for paint quality, panel alignment, and any visible signs of shoddy bodywork.
• Structural Integrity: They will look at the vehicle’s frame and undercarriage for any signs of remaining damage or improper repair.
• Functionality: They will check that lights, windows, and other basic functions work correctly.
• Overall Condition: They will assess the general state of the car, including the interior and tires.

The outcome of this inspection is the final factor in determining if you can get full coverage. If the repairs look solid and the car appears to be in excellent condition, you have a very high chance of being approved. If the inspector finds issues with the repair quality, they may approve you for liability coverage only or, in rare cases, deny coverage altogether. The outcome of their internal inspection is the final hurdle in determining if will progressive insure a rebuilt title for you.

The Cost and Limitations of Insuring a Rebuilt Title

Even after you secure a policy from Progressive, you must understand the financial realities of insuring a rebuilt title car. The coverage comes with certain trade-offs that you should consider. The savings you achieved by buying the car must be weighed against these ongoing factors.

Are Premiums Higher for Rebuilt Titles?

Yes, you can generally expect to pay a higher premium for a rebuilt title car compared to an identical model with a clean title. Insurance premiums are based on risk, and a rebuilt title vehicle is considered a higher risk. Insurers believe there is an increased chance of future mechanical or electrical failures stemming from the original damage. This increased risk is priced into your policy.

The premium increase could be modest, perhaps 10% to 20% higher than standard rates. However, the exact amount depends on the vehicle, your driving record, and the type of original damage. For example, a car rebuilt after a theft recovery with no damage might have a very small rate increase. A car rebuilt after significant flood damage will likely see a much larger surcharge. The higher premium is a key part of the answer to will progressive insure a rebuilt title; the coverage comes at a price. This ongoing cost should be factored into the total cost of ownership when you are deciding whether to buy a rebuilt car.

The Challenge of Vehicle Valuation

This is perhaps the most important limitation to understand. If you have comprehensive and collision coverage and your rebuilt car is totaled in a future accident, the insurance payout will be significantly lower. Insurance companies pay the “Actual Cash Value” (ACV) of a vehicle at the time of the loss. The ACV for a rebuilt title car is substantially less than that of a clean-title car.

Market data consistently shows that a rebuilt title reduces a car’s resale value by 20% to 40%. Insurance companies use this data to calculate your payout. For example, imagine two identical cars, each valued at $20,000. One has a clean title, and one has a rebuilt title. If both are totaled, the owner of the clean-title car might receive a payout close to $20,000. The owner of the rebuilt car might only receive a payout of $12,000 to $16,000.

You must accept this lower valuation when you purchase the policy. You are paying a higher premium for less potential coverage in a total loss scenario. This is the primary trade-off. You save money on the initial purchase of the car, but you accept more financial risk in the event of a major accident.

Final Verdict: Is Insuring a Rebuilt Title with Progressive a Good Idea?

Purchasing and insuring a rebuilt title car can be a smart financial move for the right person. It allows you to own a newer or better-equipped vehicle than you might otherwise afford. Progressive is one of the major national insurers that makes this possible. They have a clear process for evaluating and covering these vehicles.

To summarize the key points, Progressive will insure a rebuilt title car. They readily offer liability coverage once the car has passed a state inspection. Obtaining full comprehensive and collision coverage is also possible, but it requires a more involved process. You must be prepared with extensive documentation about the car’s repair history. You will likely need to speak directly with an agent and submit your vehicle for an inspection by Progressive.

The decision to move forward depends on a careful calculation. You must weigh the significant upfront savings on the car’s purchase price against the long-term realities. These include higher insurance premiums, a lower vehicle valuation in the event of a claim, and a potentially difficult resale process in the future. Ultimately, the answer to will progressive insure a rebuilt title is a conditional yes, demanding careful preparation from the vehicle owner. If you are a savvy buyer who has found a well-repaired vehicle with full documentation, getting insurance from Progressive is an achievable goal. It allows you to protect your investment and get your great deal on the road safely and legally.