What Does Comprehensive Insurance Cover?

We may earn a commission for purchases through links on our site at no cost to you, Learn more.

Car ownership in the United States brings a sense of freedom. It also brings responsibilities, including the need for proper auto insurance. Many drivers are familiar with liability insurance, which most states require. However, other types of coverage offer critical protection for your vehicle. Comprehensive insurance is one such coverage.

It protects your car from damage that is not caused by a collision. Understanding this protection is key to making informed decisions about your auto insurance policy. This guide provides a detailed explanation of comprehensive insurance, what it includes, what it excludes, and who needs it.

Understanding the Foundation of Auto Insurance

Before diving deeper into comprehensive coverage, it is important to understand its place within a standard auto insurance policy. A typical policy is a bundle of different coverages. You can choose which ones you need based on your situation and local laws.

The Three Main Types of Car Insurance

1. Liability Coverage: This is the foundation of almost every auto policy in the USA. If you cause an accident, liability coverage pays for the other party’s expenses. It is split into two parts. Bodily injury liability covers medical bills and lost wages for people you injure. Property damage liability covers repairs to the other person’s car or property that you damage. State law sets the minimum amount of liability coverage you must carry.
2. Collision Coverage: This coverage pays to repair or replace your own car after a collision. This includes accidents with other cars. It also includes accidents where you hit a stationary object, like a guardrail or a building. If your car flips over in an accident, collision coverage also applies. This coverage is optional unless a lender requires it.
3. Comprehensive Coverage: This coverage pays to repair or replace your own car after damage from non-collision events. It is the main subject of this article. Like collision coverage, it is usually optional unless you have a car loan or lease.

These three coverages work together to create a full protection plan for you and your vehicle. Liability protects your financial assets from lawsuits. Collision and comprehensive coverages protect the value of your vehicle itself.

Specific Events Covered by Comprehensive Insurance

Comprehensive insurance protects your vehicle from a specific list of events. These are incidents that do not involve a typical collision with another car. Insurance companies refer to these as “other than collision” losses. The coverage is broad and includes many common and uncommon risks.

Theft and Vandalism

One of the most significant protections comprehensive insurance offers is against crime. If your car is stolen, comprehensive coverage will pay you the actual cash value (ACV) of your vehicle, minus your deductible. The ACV is the market value of your car right before it was stolen, accounting for its age, mileage, and condition. This allows you to purchase a replacement vehicle.

Vandalism is another covered event. This includes any malicious act that damages your car. Examples include:

• Someone smashing your windows.
• Someone slashing your tires.
• Someone spray-painting graffiti on your car.
• Someone “keying” your car, scratching the paint deliberately.

Without comprehensive coverage, you would have to pay for these repairs yourself. The costs can be significant, especially for paint damage or multiple broken windows.

Weather Damage and Natural Disasters

Nature is unpredictable. Severe weather can cause major damage to a vehicle. Comprehensive insurance is your primary defense against these events.

Covered weather-related incidents include:

• Hail: Hailstones can leave dozens or even hundreds of dents on the roof, hood, and trunk of a car. The cost to repair this damage can run into thousands of dollars.
• Floods: If your car is damaged by rising water from a flood, comprehensive coverage will pay for the repairs. If the water damage is severe enough to ruin the engine or electronics, the insurance company may declare the car a total loss and pay you its ACV.
• Wind and Hurricanes: Strong winds can knock tree branches onto your car. In a hurricane, flying debris can shatter windows and dent body panels. These damages fall under comprehensive coverage.
• Tornadoes and Earthquakes: These powerful natural disasters can destroy a vehicle completely. Comprehensive coverage protects your financial investment in the car if such an event occurs.

After seeing this list of natural events, a driver might ask, what does comprehensive insurance cover when it comes to acts of nature? The answer is that it covers sudden and accidental damage from nearly all weather and geological events. It does not cover gradual damage like rust caused by living in a humid climate.

Fire, Explosions, and Falling Objects

Comprehensive insurance also covers damage from other unexpected, non-collision sources.

• Fire: This includes an engine fire, an electrical fire within the car, or a fire that spreads to your car from a nearby building or wildfire.
• Explosions: While rare, damage from an explosion is a covered event.
• Falling Objects: This is a common type of claim. It covers damage if an object falls onto your parked or moving vehicle. Examples include a tree limb breaking off in a storm, a rock falling from a cliff onto a road, or debris falling from an overpass or construction site. It also covers damage from objects kicked up by another car on the highway, such as a rock that cracks your windshield.

Animal Collisions

This is a point of frequent confusion for drivers. If you collide with another car, it is a collision claim. However, if you collide with an animal, it is a comprehensive claim. This is an important distinction because some drivers carry comprehensive coverage but not collision coverage.

Events covered include:

• Hitting a deer that runs onto the road.
• Colliding with a dog, coyote, or other domestic or wild animal.
• Damage caused by a rodent chewing through wiring under your hood.

The logic is that an animal’s behavior is unpredictable, much like a hailstorm or a falling tree branch. The incident is not considered a standard driving-related collision. This can be beneficial for the policyholder, as comprehensive claims sometimes have a smaller impact on future premiums than at-fault collision claims.

Glass Damage

Broken or cracked glass is a very common issue. Comprehensive coverage typically pays for the repair or replacement of your windshield, side windows, and rear window. This includes damage from rocks, debris, vandalism, and weather.

Many insurance companies offer a separate, lower deductible for glass-only claims. Some even offer a zero-dollar deductible for windshield repairs, as fixing a small chip is much cheaper than replacing the entire windshield later. This encourages drivers to fix small issues before they become big, dangerous cracks.

Civil Disturbances

Damage that occurs during a riot or other civil commotion is also covered. If your car is overturned, set on fire, or otherwise damaged during a protest or public disturbance, comprehensive insurance will pay for the repairs.

What Comprehensive Insurance Does Not Cover

It is equally important to understand the exclusions of a comprehensive policy. Knowing what is not covered helps you avoid surprises when you file a claim and ensures you have the right coverage for all your needs.

Collisions with Vehicles or Objects

This is the most important exclusion. As its name implies, collision coverage handles crashes. Comprehensive insurance never covers damage from an accident where you hit another car or an object like a fence, a pole, or a building. It also does not cover damage if your car rolls over due to a driving error. For these incidents, you need to have purchased separate collision coverage.

Personal Belongings Inside Your Car

Comprehensive insurance covers the car itself and its factory-installed parts. It does not cover personal items that are stolen from your car or damaged in a covered event. For example, if a thief breaks your window and steals your laptop, comprehensive coverage will pay to fix the window. It will not pay to replace the laptop.

Coverage for personal items like laptops, smartphones, or gym equipment typically comes from a homeowners or renters insurance policy. These policies usually include “off-premises” coverage for your belongings, even when they are in your car.

Custom Parts and Equipment

Standard comprehensive policies provide very limited coverage for custom parts or equipment you add to your car. This includes things like:

• Aftermarket stereos and speakers
• Custom rims and tires
• Special paint jobs
• Spoilers and body kits

Most policies have a low limit for this equipment, often around $1,000 or $1,500. If you have invested a lot of money in customizing your vehicle, you will need to purchase an additional endorsement called “Custom Parts and Equipment (CPE)” coverage. This endorsement increases the coverage limit to protect your investment.

Wear and Tear or Mechanical Failure

Insurance is designed to cover sudden and accidental losses. It is not a maintenance plan. Therefore, comprehensive insurance does not cover damage that results from normal wear and tear or a lack of maintenance.

Examples of excluded issues include:

• Engine failure due to old age or lack of oil changes.
• Tires wearing out over time.
• Rust developing on the body panels.
• Brakes failing from normal use.

These are considered routine ownership costs that the car owner is responsible for. The only exception is if a mechanical failure leads directly to a covered comprehensive loss. For example, if a faulty wire causes a fire that damages the car, the fire damage would be covered. The cost to repair the faulty wire itself would not be.

Financial Aspects of Comprehensive Coverage

When you use your comprehensive insurance, there are two key financial concepts you must understand: the deductible and the coverage limit.

How the Deductible Works

A deductible is the amount of money you must pay out of pocket before your insurance coverage begins to pay. You choose your deductible amount when you buy your policy. Common deductible amounts are $250, $500, and $1,000.

Here is a simple example:

Your car sustains heavy damage in a hailstorm. The repair shop estimates the cost of repairs at $4,000. Your comprehensive deductible is $500.

• You pay the first $500 of the repair bill.
• Your insurance company pays the remaining $3,500.

Choosing a higher deductible will lower your insurance premium. This is because you are agreeing to take on more financial risk yourself. Choosing a lower deductible will increase your premium, as the insurance company is taking on more risk. You should choose a deductible amount that you can comfortably afford to pay at any time.

Coverage Limits and Actual Cash Value (ACV)

Comprehensive insurance does not pay an unlimited amount to fix your car. The maximum amount an insurance company will pay for a claim is the actual cash value (ACV) of your vehicle at the moment just before the damage occurred.

If the cost to repair your car is greater than its ACV, the insurance company will declare it a “total loss.” In this case, they will not pay for the repairs. Instead, they will write you a check for the car’s ACV, minus your deductible. You then use that money to buy a new vehicle. The insurance company takes possession of the damaged car.

This concept is very important for owners of older cars. If your car is only worth $2,000, and the repair cost for a covered event is $3,000, it will be totaled. The insurance company will pay you $2,000 minus your deductible.

This complete picture helps clarify the central question: what does comprehensive insurance cover from a financial standpoint? It covers the cost of repairs or the value of the car, but only after you have paid your share (the deductible) and only up to the car’s pre-damage value (the ACV).

Is Comprehensive Insurance Right for You?

Unlike liability coverage, no state legally requires you to carry comprehensive insurance. The decision to buy it depends on your financial situation, your vehicle, and your personal tolerance for risk.

When Comprehensive Coverage is Required

There is one major situation where you will be required to have comprehensive insurance: if you have a loan or a lease on your car. The bank or leasing company that financed the vehicle is a part-owner until you pay it off. They require you to carry both comprehensive and collision coverage to protect their financial investment. If the car is stolen or destroyed in a flood, the lender wants to ensure their loan gets paid back. Once you have paid off the loan and own the car outright, the choice to keep comprehensive coverage is yours.

When Comprehensive Coverage is a Smart Choice

Even if it is not required, comprehensive coverage is a good idea for many drivers. Consider buying it if:

• Your car is new or has a high value. If your car is worth $10,000 or more, a total loss would be a major financial setback. Comprehensive coverage protects this asset.
• You cannot afford to replace your car. If you do not have enough savings to buy another car if yours is stolen or destroyed, you should carry comprehensive coverage.
• You live in an area with specific risks. If your region experiences frequent hailstorms, hurricanes, or high rates of auto theft, the odds of needing to file a comprehensive claim are higher. In this case, the coverage is a very sensible investment.
• You want complete peace of mind. For many people, the relatively small cost of comprehensive coverage is worth the peace of mind that comes from knowing they are protected from a wide range of unfortunate events.

When You Might Consider Dropping Comprehensive Coverage

There comes a point in a car’s life when comprehensive coverage may no longer be cost-effective. You might consider dropping it if:

• Your car has a very low market value. As a car gets older, its ACV decreases. Eventually, the value may be so low that the cost of the insurance is not worth the potential payout.
• The premium and deductible approach the car’s value. A good rule of thumb is to compare the cost of coverage to the car’s value. Calculate the annual cost of your comprehensive premium. Add your deductible to that amount. If this total is close to or more than the ACV of your car, it may be time to drop the coverage.

For example, your car is worth $1,500. Your comprehensive deductible is $1,000, and the annual premium for it is $300. In a total loss scenario, the most the insurance company would pay you is $500 ($1,500 ACV – $1,000 deductible). It might not be worth paying $300 per year for a maximum potential benefit of $500. In this situation, it could be wiser to save that premium money for future car repairs or a down payment on a new vehicle.

Conclusion: A Vital Protection for Your Vehicle

So, what does comprehensive insurance cover in summary? It is a crucial form of auto insurance that protects your vehicle from damage caused by events other than a collision. It pays for losses from theft, vandalism, weather, fire, animal collisions, and falling objects. It provides a financial safety net for events that are often sudden, unexpected, and entirely beyond your control.

This coverage works alongside liability and collision insurance to create a full shield of protection for you and your car. While it does not cover collisions, personal items, or normal wear and tear, its value in protecting your automotive asset is undeniable for most owners. The decision to carry it involves a careful assessment of your car’s value, your financial situation, the requirements of your lender, and your personal comfort with risk. By understanding exactly what comprehensive insurance includes and excludes, you can make a smart, informed choice that ensures you are prepared for whatever the road—and life—throws your way. Review your policy, speak with an insurance professional, and build the coverage that is right for you.